There are two Peter MacCallum's born in Prince Edward about the same time. One is Peter Stainforth MacCallum, born in 1875, to Robert Douglas MacCallum and Annie McLean, and the other is Peter MacCallum, born c 1878 to Dougald MacCallum and Catherine MacKinnon.
There are those who have claimed the Peter in our tree to be the son of Dougald and Catherine MacCallum, and some pick up this information without researching it and so the myth is perpertrated. I have set about to prove that our Peter MacCallum is the son of Robert D MacCallum and Annie McLean. I have no doubt about the existence of the other Peter; I just want to prove that our Peter, who married Edith Maude Steeves, is the son of Robert and Annie and the grandson of Peter MacCallum and Susanna Ford Cutler of St. Peters Bay, Prince Edward Island.
This is background research for an article I am writing for the Holmes Family Newsletter of November, 2014.
These are some of the sources I used to prove my hopothesis that Peter Stainforth MacCallum, who married Edith Maude Steeves (date unknown), is indeed the son of Robert and Annie (McLean) MacCallum. I won't share them all; the newsletter must include a few surprises, after all. They are in no particular order, except for the Censuses.
1. US WWI Draft Registration. I can see the original card.
Gives full name: Peter Stainforth MacCallum. Address 6 Highland Park, Roxbury, Massachusetts. Age 49; date of birth Mar 22, 1875, Canada, PEI. White. Naturalized. Occupation chauffeur for R. P. Sherman. Married to Edith M MacCallum of same address. Date of registration Sep 12, 1918.
2. U S Social Sec Death Index. This is a transcription.
Gives S S Number.
Residence Quincy, Massachusetts. Date of birth 22 Mar 1875. Date of death Feb 1968.
3. U S Naturalization Records. Original Card; M 245.
McCallum, Peter S
Address: 20 Beldon St. Boston,
Certificate Number 440-18
Title and Location of Court USCC Boston Mass
Country or Birth of Allegience Great Britain
Date of Birth March 22, 1875
Date of Naturalization October 9, 1905
4. Massachusetts Marriage Records. A transcription
Peter S MacCallum
Born c 1875 Canada
Married 15 April 1902, Boston, age 27
Father Robert D MacCallum
Mother Annie McLean
Spouse Sarah D McDonald
Daughter of Daniel H McDonald and Sarah McKenzie
5. 1881 Census of Canada. Can see original.
Lot 41, PEI: important that this lots is St. Peters Bay, PEI. (Also, the history of PEI being divided into lots is interesting, but another story.)
Stainforth McCallum
Age 4 born 1877 Prince Edward Island; Presbyterian. Others in household:
Father Robert McCallum Methodist, Farmer, Age 43
Mother Annie McCallum Presbyterian
Children:
Helen Age 13
Eben 12
Arlitte 10
Grace D 8
Jane C 6
Stainforth 4
Imogene1
Other person Jane Robertson age 70
6. 1900 U S Census Boston. Can see original. Ward 10 District 1299; two things that interest me. One is his occupation, the other is that is district is 1299 and the district where three Steeves brothers live and work as butchers is 1289. I would like to know if these districts are close enough that he could have known the Steeves brothers and perhaps worked in the same market.
McCallum, Peter S
Age 23 Born March 1877 Canada
Home in 1900 Boston
Born Prince Edward Island, Canada
Immigration year 1891
Occupation Clerk in grocery store
Mother Annie McCallum, age 40, orn Sept 1859, widowed.
Children: Grace, Peter, Jennie, Imogene
7. 1910 U S Census. Can see original
P S Maccalum
Age 35. Born abt 1875, Canada
White, male
Residence Seattle, Washington
Immigration year 1892
Spouse Sadie D Maccalum
Occupation Carpenter, Bridge Industry
8. 1920 U S Census. Can see original
Peter S MacCullum
Age 44, born c 1876 in PEI
Residence Charles St, Boston
Immigration Year 1892
Married to Edith MacCullum
Occupation Shipwright in Navy Yard
One daughter, Shirley E
Also Caroline Steeves (mother in law) age 70 and Lloyd E Steeves (brother in law)
9. 1930 U S Census. Can see original
Born abt 1875 Canada
Residence Quincy Massachusetts
Immigration year 1905 (My note: that is his year of naturalization)
Spouse Edith M MacCallum
Occupation: Ship-builder, Naval yard
Also at that residence: Shirley age 11, Caroline M Steeves (mother in law) age 81
10. 1940 U S Census
Peter S MacCallum
Age 65 born c 1875
Residence 50 Taylor St, Quincy
Completed 8th grade
No occupation
Also at that residence: Edith age 57, Shirley E age 21
What I would like to know:
Date and place of death of his first wife, Sarah MacDonald
Date and place of marriage of Peter and Edith
If Peter MacCallum knew the Steeves family before he moved to Seattle.
I am absolutely convinced that Peter Stainforth MacCallum is the son of Robert Douglas MacCallum and Annie McLean.
Sept. 22. I found the marriage record of Peter and Edith at ancestry.com. It comes from a transcription and is a typed list of people married in Boston. From this I learned that Peter was 39, Edith was 30. It was Peter's second marriage and Edith's first; Peter was a widower. Peter's residence was Seattle, WA, and Edith's was 10 Greenville Street, Boston. Peter was a bridge carpenter and Edith was at home. Peter was born in PEI and Edith in NB. Peter's parents were Robert D MacCallum and Annie MacLean. Edith's were Charles A Steeves and Caroline M Holmes. Married by clergyman Rev. Charles A Fulton.